An outline of the success of Apple+

(from left) Bob (voiced by Simon Pegg) and Sam Greenfield (voiced by Eva Noblezada) in Luck.

(from left) Bob (voiced by Simon Pegg) and Sam Greenfield (voiced by Eva Noblezada) Good luck.
Photo: Apple+

Highly innovative on both a technological and narrative level, Pixar helped advance the medium of animation and once and for all shatter the notion that mainstream animated films couldn’t be complex and ambitious without alienating or including their (typical) core family demographic. John Lasseter as Director Toy Story and chief creative officer of Pixar, has been at the forefront of this shift.

Then it gets especially confusing Good luck, the shockingly dark debut film from Lasseter’s new Skydance Animation, came out with such a bang. The film’s fallacious reasoning and sharp beats make it clear that Lasseter’s disdainful professional defense (he was kicked out of bed in 2017-2018 amid allegations of sexual misconduct) affected his narrative and the competence and skill level of the people willing to work with him. , or both.

After leaving the group home she called home for a long time, 18-year-old orphan Sam (Eva Noblezada) gets her first apartment and job. After receiving a magical penny that removes her seemingly eternal misfortune for a few hours, Sam plans to give it to her young friend and fellow orphan Hazel before the latter’s meeting with a potential adoptive family, only to lose the coin at the last minute.

When Sam crosses paths again with Bob (Simon Pegg), a black Scottish cat whom she sees as a harbinger of good luck, he runs away. Sam gives chase and returns to his home, an alternate dimension called “Land of Luck”, where both good and bad luck is produced and then channeled to Earth. The happy, positive side is populated by leprechauns and bunnies, though for some reason they are overseen by a 40-foot dragon named Babe (Jane Fonda). There is also a downside, as well as the space “Between” properly sandwiched between these two lands.

Sam and Bob, with the help of the latter’s leper friend Gerry (Colin O’Donoghue), try to evade the captain (Whoopi Goldberg), head of security at the stern Land of Fortune, and get their hands on a lucky penny they can use to help. both of them.

To say that Good luck struggles with non-verbal storytelling is a huge understatement. The screenplay by Kiel Murray (from the story with Glenn Berger and Jonathan Aibel) is somewhat paradoxically lazy and incredibly overwritten. A lot of the details seem odd (the leprechauns just exist to grind pennies), perhaps the result of a push and pull development, and overall the script is full of a lot of holes that never seem to go away. One of the most prominent examples of this is the store manager, Marv (Lil Rel Howery), who greets Sam on his first day on the job by saying, “You might be the best decision I’ve ever made!”

For long-standing principled opponents Cars and a spinoff Airplanes franchises that raise many troubling questions about those worlds, as well as the entire class of vehicles that serve them, Good luck There is also probably one major oddity: What is the genesis of this universe and why do all its inhabitants exist to provide humans with riches that few of them ever meet? Good luck simply shrugs off any honest interaction with his environment.

Most frustrating though Good luck a depressing story that is extremely quest-oriented. In the absence of really well-crafted world-building, with a certain sense of wonder and whimsy that can capture and hold a child’s (or even an adult’s) imagination, so many languages ​​are spoken. Not to mention how many monologues list the series of quests for a certain quest, or explain the existence of a “success randomization mechanism,” or how crystals are smashed into dust before being shipped out.

It’s one thing to repeatedly channel a lot of exposition or a functional plot through a single character; While still suboptimal overall, this most masterful representation can be incorporated into that character’s personality. But it’s a symptom of a deeper problem, with multiple characters constantly explaining the scope of its world, the relationships between its inhabitants, and nearly every interaction.

Success – Official Trailer | Apple TV+

The result is a film that feels like a very colorful, moving instruction manual where things just… just happen. Sometimes that means there’s some cute physical comedy, like Bob trying to escape Sam as he walks through a row of opening umbrellas. But more often than not, scenes are cut short by a tried-and-true idea (line dancing with bunnies!) that is nothing more than a narrative escape chute.

Director Peggy Holmes took over Kung Fu Panda 3 co-director Alessandro Carloni (who quit due to creative differences) either during production or just before most of the main animation, depending on which story is believed. This smallness is felt because the film lacks clear control and, frankly, effort. Good luckthe visual design is soft, pleasant, but not necessarily ambitious; it relies on generally attractive, eye-catching character designs and doesn’t create well-detailed backgrounds.

Will young children notice? Yes, but not in the way they could express – which is actually a blessing, because after that Good luckthe best happiness one can hope for is a longer silence.

Leave a Comment